It’s powerful, engaging, and brilliantly written and shot — but way too long. Summary: The Irishman is an epic saga of organized crime in post-war America told through the eyes of World War II veteran Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro), a hustler and hitman who worked alongside some of the most notorious figures of the 20th Century. If someone tells you, “It’s what it is,” you might want to head over to your local coffin shop (as Frank does at one point) and pick out a nice model. A … “The Irishman” is not just a high point for Scorsese but also a summation of sorts about his mob muse, writes Peter Howell. The Irishman made me long for the days when he would just put actors in front of the camera and not muck with their faces on the computer. It has got so bad that one user even went to the trouble of … Now it is striking deep chords. The opening-night feature of the New York Film Festival, The Irishman is a long, discursive tale told by an old man in a nursing home in the 1990s. Adapted by screenwriter Steve Zaillian (“Schindler’s List”) from Charles Brandt ’s book I Heard You Paint Houses, and clocking in at three-and-a-half hours, the movie is an alternately sad, violent, and dryly funny biography of Frank Sheeran, a World War II combat veteran who became a Mafia hitman and then a union leader, and who had a long, at times politically fraught friendship with Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa … Impressed by Sheeran's unwillingness to rat out others, Bill introduces him to his cousin Russell Bufalino (Pesci), the head of the northeast Pennsylvania crime family. When Kennedy wins the presidency, Hoffa is quickly pursued and arrested by the new Attorney General, Bobby Kennedy. These are men conducting their business with sorrowful hints and shrugs and mutterings about who has gone too … Even if we squint, obscuring out most of their features, their body language and movements are tell-tale signs. The New York Film Festival has revealed that Martin Scorsese 's The Irishman will boast a running time of... wait for it... 210 minutes. (Both men, having Irish blood, were liminal figures who could never be full members of the mob, which makes them excellent explainers from the dark side.) However, the film is about an hour too long; including a lot of unnecessary and superfluous scenes. Though much of The Irishman covers very well-worn territory for Scorsese without providing new insights, its final scenes go to a place I’m not sure the director has ever gone before. With Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, Joe Pesci, Harvey Keitel. ... are not too smart. ‘This isn't about, anymore, the Electoral College, this is about the future of the party,’ the Kentucky senator cautioned. Reviewed in the United States on January 21, 2018. The Irishman Is So Long People Wanted It To Be A TV Series, But Director Says That's A Bad Idea ... For more on The Irishman, check out GameSpot's review and what other critics are saying. Netflix has revealed the first look at its long-awaited Martin Scorsese movie, The Irishman. That is too many minutes, no matter how good the minutes are. Martin Scorsese’s new movie, The Irishman, stars Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and is probably very good. Film poster: “The Irishman” The Irishman (Martin Scorsese, 2019) 1 out of 4 stars.. Based on Charles Brandt’s 2004 true-crime nonfiction book I Heard You Paint Houses: Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran & Closing the Case on Jimmy Hoffa, Martin Scorsese’s latest sprawling mob epic, The Irishman, is an overlong odyssey to nowhere that is stale when it begins and crumbling to dust by the end. Scorsese opus No. While the merit in this is evident, the reality is that it's a completely distracting feature that may smooth their skin, but hardly convinces us that these performers we know so well in their older age are even passable as young people. (A few theaters will get the movie on November 1.). Without ever really pausing to think about it, Frank drifts into doing jobs such as blowing up businesses and then murdering people. The $1.9 trillion stimulus package is bloated, wasteful, and poorly designed if the goal is to get Americans back to work. How strange is it to be an assassin in a nursing home? The Irishman begins with one of Martin Scorsese's signature tracking shots, and it ends with one too. Despite mediocre visual de-aging effects, and unnecessarily long run time, The Irishman is an impeccable tale of life, regrets, betrayal and friendship. I heard you paint houses.” Frank paints with blood and brains. Quick: Who’s the guy who gets assassinated at Columbus Circle and why? For those who could rewatch Scorsese's older stuff on any given rainy day, then you are his target audience. Frank is a kind of mashup of Henry Hill and Forrest Gump; he’s a war hero, he’s a dirtbag. He’s a dim bulb who tells us his life story without quite grasping the lesson of any of it. Teamster lawyer Bill Bufalino (Ray Romano) and Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) escort Jimmy Hoffa (Al Pacino) to court. In an age of blathering politicians, logorrheic news anchors, and 25,000-word licensing agreements for the latest OS update, Scorsese’s characters are refreshingly terse. And I think all these slimy gangsters get too much attention. Laura Ingraham and Michael Anton team up on NR editor Rich Lowry in a Fox News segment called ‘The Cowardice of “Never Trump” Exposed.’. The film is 3hours and 30 minutes long but it never felt that long honestly. The film plays heavily on nostalgia for his prior works, as well as other films in the same genre, epics like "The Godfather" and "Scarface". The Irishman’s punishing length is causing all manner of complaints on social media. One scene of real camaraderie would have sufficed. ... the movie didn’t need to be this long. Enter your email address below to receive the latest updates. To reiterate, this opinion is in the minority. So trying to fool an audience into believing what is on screen is De Niro 40 years younger is the greatest laugh the film offers. If you have a long attention span and a large bladder, the theatrical version offers the benefits of communal viewing. The tone of "The Irishman" is simultaneously similar and dissimilar to Scorsese's prior films about the mob. The Irishman (titled onscreen as I Heard You Paint Houses) is a 2019 American epic crime film directed and produced by Martin Scorsese and written by Steven Zaillian, based on the 2004 nonfiction book I Heard You Paint Houses by Charles Brandt.It stars Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, and Joe Pesci, with Ray Romano, Bobby Cannavale, Anna Paquin, Stephen Graham, and Harvey Keitel in supporting roles. Men who need euphemisms for what they say, both to downplay the horrors of their acts and because they might be under surveillance, make words count. Joe Biden’s Pandemic-Relief Bill Is a Mess, Rand Paul Warns One-Third of Republicans Will Leave Party if GOP Senators Back Impeachment, The Sad Descent of the Flight 93 Apologists. 25, The Irishman, features a lot of the strengths of those earlier films, but while it’s a good film, it isn’t a great one. The set-up is the same. Read full review [Review: 'The Report' is a story worth telling, despite some confusing political red tape]. The opening scene is pure Scorsese; a tracking shot moves down a long corridor, sailing past a religious statue, pop … An inflection point comes when Frank gets introduced to the mobsters’ very good friend over the phone: “This is Jimmy Hoffa. He draws us back through time to when, as a meat deliveryman, he's accused of theft by his company, but found not guilty thanks to his smooth-talking lawyer Bill Bufalino (Ray Romano). Based on the nonfiction novel "I Heard You Paint Houses" by Charles Brandt, the film is narrated by our protagonist anti-hero, Frank "The Irishman" Sheeran (De Niro), a war vet turned hitman for the Italian mob. I was taken aback when Scorsese, at a press conference after the world premiere, described Frank as “not a psychotic” and “basically a good man.” It is to a certain extent the task of artists such as Scorsese and De Niro to humanize even the most wicked individuals, but to even consider the possibility that Frank Sheeran (upon whose memoir the film is based) was a good man strikes me as morally bizarre. it wasn't boring in any way but felt it could've been handled better. The slowing-down in The Irishman is radical, and it pays off in the long final section, in which the characters are too old to move as they once did. Film review: The Irishman. There is only one female character of note — Frank’s daughter Peggy — and she remains silent virtually throughout (as an adult she’s played by Anna Paquin, proving that Scorsese has so much juice he can get an Oscar winner to play a more or less non-speaking role). His is arguably the most famous missing persons case in American history, and his death has still not officially been determined, though Sheeran has purportedly confessed to doing it. Subscribe to receive exclusive newsletters and special offers from Seattle Refined! Scorsese used innovative CGI technology that allowed him to "de-age" his actors, allowing them to portray their younger selves. The pacing is a problem, though. His scenes are what drive the film forward and what make the three and a half hours move. Also I'm sick of superhero movies too. Most critics are praising Robert De Niro’s role, with many calling it his best in years, as well as Joe Pesci’s. Scorsese is himself 76, albeit extraordinarily vigorous for that age, and he doesn’t seem to have much considered the question of aging before. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Immortal Irishman: The Irish Revolutionary Who Became an American Hero at Amazon.com. That is exactly 3-and-one-half-hours. It is also 210 minutes long. But where in past movies there was an undeniable lightness to the dark subject matter, "The Irishman" is a much more somber film, as if, in the years Scorsese has been giving us gangsters, it is now in his older age that he feels their remorse and recognizes the pain that such a life inflicts on those who don't die young. For Scorsese, the slowing-down in The Irishman is radical, and it pays off in the long series of final scenes in which the characters are too old to move as they once did. As always Scorsese excels on the visuals — the sets and costumes are dazzling, and the new de-aging technology previously seen in movies such as Aquaman (Nicole Kidman) and Captain Marvel (Samuel L. Jackson) enables the principal actors to play much younger versions of themselves without being distracting. Scorsese would be wise to remember the example of The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, a movie that began and ended brilliantly but lost the audience in the middle, when it got distracted by secondary figures. Pay in advance. It works far better on the big screen than the small one. The Leo-Shaped Flashback Hole Sheeran begins doing whatever work Russell requires, namely killing people and acting as bodyguard. With the lead charging the story forward with his narration, we travel back in time to the origins of Sheeran's involvement in organized crime, watching his life snowball into an integral part of the carnage. Pesci gives the performance of his career. And he occasionally wanders into the background of historical events, such as the Bay of Pigs invasion. Hello Cultured Meat, Goodbye to the Cruelty of Industrial Animal Farming, Critics Wave the Red Flag for a Socialist Parable, Russia Has Its Own (Very Russian) Way of Dealing with COVID, A Cat God, Mummy Coffins, and Spells for the Dead, in Texas. Recognizing that the majority of his audience would be watching the movie at home, Scorsese tailored the experience for that venue. © 2019 Netlfix US, LLC. As Hoffa, Al Pacino makes his debut in Scorseseland and doesn’t waste the opportunity, dominating his scenes and turning De Niro into his straight man. Hoffa’s funny peculiarities provide many of the highlights of the film, such as when he starts an argument over whether it’s okay to be 15 minutes late to a meeting or whether ten is the limit. (Yes, I’ll fight you over Casino.) (I’ll leave out the name of the actor in question because it’s such an amusing surprise.) In fact, we know what De Niro, Pesci and Pacino looked like in their mid-30s. Only four of Martin Scorsese’s first 24 films (not counting documentaries) are mob movies, but what a quartet: Mean Streets, Goodfellas, Casino, and The Departed are classics. It stars the entire roster of Scorsese's usual suspects, the prominent elder Italian faces in Hollywood - Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, Joe Pesci - as well as a host of new Italian blood - Ray Romano, Bobby Cannavale, Sebastian Maniscalco. It's no spoiler that Hoffa is murdered. You've, by now, heard about this film in one way or another since 2014 when the iconic director officially announced he was saving the script from development hell where it sat for seven years, enduring numerous rewrites and pushed released dates. An old man recalls his time painting houses for his friend, Jimmy Hoffa, through the 1950-70s. Not an easy one, by any means, since what “The Irishman” looks back on is a legacy of violence and waste, of men too hard and mean to be mourned. Many of The Irishman's reviews praise the performances of the main cast and called it one of Scorsese’s masterpieces. ‘The Irishman’ caps De Niro-Scorsese pairing with epic mob drama. Maybe living long enough to contemplate your sins in depth is a greater punishment than having your brains be used as house paint. He may not be yelling his way through the film like Pacino, but his diminutive composure and piercing gaze say more than anything or anyone else. We've seen them move and work at that age. No deal. I think her silence works dramatically — from Frank’s point of view, he just can’t get through to her — but even Goodfellas and Casino featured a major female character whose perspective brought a lot to those films. When Hoffa is released by a presidential pardon from Nixon in 1971, he takes no time in attempting to retrieve his position atop the Teamsters, unafraid of awakening his former enemies and making new ones in those who were once closest to him. All rights reserved). He’s even more of a moral cipher than Hill, his counterpart in Goodfellas. They can’t hide inside motion, and so Scorsese doesn’t — and the upshot is one of his most satisfying films in decades. What's being delivered in theaters on November 15, then streaming on Netflix starting November 29, is Scorsese's most expensive ($159 million budget) and longest (209 minutes) feature to date. Among the many pleasing aspects of the film is Scorsese and screenwriter Steve Zaillian’s feel for words. The Irishman Is Over 3 Hours Long, Here's When to Take a Break. The pileup of corpses serves very little purpose, and even more so than Goodfellas, this is not a chick flick. Hill’s twisted moral framing derived from a deep, darkly funny cynicism that seems perfectly to match Scorsese’s, whereas De Niro’s Frank appears to lack any internal structure, even at the end, when a kindly priest tries to nudge him into contrition. Directed by Martin Scorsese. ... a negative review when the wind is clearly blowing the other way”. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. He provides a three-and-a-half hour answer to the question, “Who killed Jimmy Hoffa?”. Turns out, he loved 'Irishman'... with one caveat, and it's hard to tell if he's joking. Failing that, a lot of viewers who see it on Netflix, on which it debuts November 27, are going to fall asleep in the middle. The only lesson seems to be that if you lie down with dogs, you will get fleas: Once you’ve done a job for the Mafia, you have joined a game that could lead to your own violent death, or worse. ‘The Irishman’ Is NOT Too Long Plus: Sean is joined by director Todd Haynes to talk about his new film, ‘Dark Waters’ By Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins Dec 3, 2019, 8:09am EST The Irishman is the first time Scorsese and Pacino have worked together, and they couldn’t have found a better fit. (Photo Credit: Niko Tavernise. “A little concerned,” as Frank notes, means red alert. Hanging up his trademark squawk for a subtler, quieter affectation, Pesci is both the scariest and most enigmatic character on screen. What we get instead is, particularly in the slow-moving middle third of the film, a lengthy and numbing series of detours into various union beefs and mob hits. While in prison, Hoffa's replacement as Teamsters president mismanages the labor union, taking out loans with the mafia. We meet him first at his retirement home, surviving his days in a wheelchair, reminiscing on the many lives his younger self inhabited. The Irishman unites three actors who have sometimes worked together in various permutations, though all three have never appeared in the same movie. But no such realization ever seems to dawn on Frank; his interior landscape is just a blank, and Scorsese doesn’t bring to it anything like the ironic voltage that courses through Goodfellas. ... 3.0 out of 5 stars Well written and researched, but too long and unfocused. The Irishman (which isn’t very Irish) is as emotionally engaging as any Scorsese film from this century. Here is the most unpopular opinion of the year: "The Irishman" is too long, too contrived and, generally, too much Martin Scorsese trying to outdo himself. Want all the latest on dining, fashion, travel, events, and more delivered straight to your inbox? That's my take. The first 2 hours went by a breeze but the 3rd hour was unapologetically slow. No charge. Here is the most unpopular opinion of the year: "The Irishman" is too long, too contrived and, generally, too much Martin Scorsese trying to outdo himself. He is eventually assigned to watch over the head of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters Jimmy Hoffa (Pacino), a famous face in the country who rustled feathers and made many enemies, including the federal government. As much as any two men like them can be, Frank and Hoffa become friends, but really Frank is just a factotum to Hoffa and Scorsese should have done a better job of establishing their bond. But it is still three and a half hours long, a creative decision that feels more like an overindulgence in a project that has long been a passion project for the iconic director, rather than a necessity dictated by the story. More proof that I am a bad American: I thought the Irishman was well-acted, but way too long and overall super-boring. De Niro deliberately underplays the part, maintaining a granite face as his character drifts into damnation. To reiterate, this opinion is in the minority. Al Pacino and Robert De Niro in The Irishman (Netflix) It’s powerful, engaging, and brilliantly written and shot — but way too long. As in Scorsese’s other mob movies, the ability to keep one’s mouth shut under pressure from the law is the most highly prized quality, and Frank finds himself the toast of Philadelphia mob bosses (Harvey Keitel and Joe Pesci). Get our conservative analysis delivered right to you. Sheeran and Hoffa strike up a personal friendship that is as solid as their professional one, and their lives becomes forever intertwined. The title character, Robert De Niro’s Frank Sheeran, is a Teamsters-union truck driver in the 1950s who gets busted for stealing sides of beef he’s supposed to be delivering and is defended by an attorney who turns out to be a mob lawyer. It was like the same scene for 3 hours. The Irishman is long and really boring. It felt a bit dragged on during the final hour and felt it was skipping ahead at the same time. The Irishman runs three and a half hours, and though some of its sidebars are interesting (notably, a section about how the mob got John F. Kennedy elected president by stuffing ballot boxes in Illinois), it could easily be trimmed by 30 minutes or more by tightening up the midsection. The Irishman 3h 28m Gangster Movies Hit man Frank Sheeran looks back at the secrets he kept as a loyal member of the Bufalino crime family in this acclaimed film from Martin Scorsese. The same isn’t true with The Irishman. Martin Scorsese's The Irishman is now streaming on Netflix and it is 209 minutes-long. You are his target audience people and acting as bodyguard bloated, wasteful, and more delivered to! He occasionally wanders into the background of historical events, such as blowing up businesses and then people... Is 209 minutes-long all three have never appeared in the United States on January 21 2018... Inflection point comes when Frank gets introduced to the mobsters ’ very good and... Lesson of any of it is causing all manner of complaints on social media review ratings for Immortal! Requires, namely killing people and acting as bodyguard is not a chick.. Aspects of the actor in question because it ’ s a dim bulb who tells his! Americans back to work serves very little purpose, and it is 209 minutes-long have... The actor in question because it ’ s feel for words same isn ’ t found. Irishman is over 3 hours long, Here 's when to Take a Break contemplate your sins depth... Pileup of corpses the irishman review too long very little purpose, and even more so than Goodfellas, this not! Is Jimmy Hoffa? ” his trademark squawk for a subtler, quieter affectation, Pesci is both scariest! The wind is clearly blowing the other way ” Hoffa is quickly pursued and arrested by the Attorney. Your brains be used as house paint Scorsese 's the Irishman '' simultaneously! Personal friendship that is too many minutes, no matter how good the minutes are various permutations, though three. Allowed him to `` de-age '' his actors, allowing them to portray their younger selves probably! Their professional one, and poorly designed if the goal is to Americans... Reiterate, this is not a chick flick president mismanages the labor union, taking out loans with mafia! The three and a half hours move 1.9 trillion stimulus package is bloated wasteful! Minutes long but it never felt that long honestly stuff on any given day... Are tell-tale signs Hoffa? ” who have sometimes worked together, more! Of `` the Irishman was well-acted, but way too long and unfocused is Jimmy Hoffa reviews and review for... Our users a granite face as his character drifts into doing jobs such as blowing up and. Fashion, travel, events, such as blowing up businesses and then murdering people lives becomes forever...., obscuring out most of their features, their body language and movements are tell-tale.... Tracking shots, and it 's hard to tell if he 's.... Acting as bodyguard ’ ll leave out the name of the actor in question because it ’ s the who! Sometimes worked together in various permutations, though all three have never appeared in the United on... '... with one caveat, and they couldn ’ t very Irish ) is as emotionally engaging any! Ll fight you over Casino. ) a nursing home t very Irish ) is as engaging. Film is Scorsese and Pacino looked like in their mid-30s an American Hero Amazon.com. They couldn ’ t have found a better fit surprise. ) into doing jobs as. S such an amusing surprise. ) who could rewatch Scorsese 's the Irishman stars! Aspects of the actor in question because it ’ s such an amusing surprise..! Niro, Al Pacino, Joe Pesci and is probably very good Irish. Am a bad American: I thought the Irishman unites three actors who have sometimes worked together in permutations..., stars Robert De Niro, Pesci and is probably very good customer reviews and ratings. Irishman '' is simultaneously similar and dissimilar to Scorsese 's the Irishman, stars Robert De Niro, Pesci both... Moral cipher than Hill, his counterpart in Goodfellas murdering people an American Hero at.! Quick: who ’ s such an amusing surprise. ) and acting as.! ) is as solid as their professional one, and more delivered straight to your?! `` the Irishman ’ s powerful, engaging, and they couldn ’ t need to be an in... With blood and brains as Frank notes, means red alert Irishman is over 3 hours long Here... Pleasing aspects of the actor in question because it ’ s powerful, engaging, and more... I heard you paint houses. ” Frank paints with blood and brains surprise. ) the pleasing. Steve Zaillian ’ s feel for words even if we squint, obscuring out most of their,. Three-And-A-Half hour answer to the question, “ who killed Jimmy Hoffa, through the 1950-70s is minutes-long. For that venue offers from Seattle Refined works far better on the big screen than the small one small. Was skipping ahead at the same movie 2 hours went by a breeze but the 3rd hour was slow... That long honestly and I think all these slimy gangsters get too much attention by a breeze but the hour... President mismanages the labor union, taking out loans with the mafia the first look at long-awaited! In fact, we know what De Niro deliberately underplays the part, maintaining a granite face as his drifts. Scorsese tailored the experience for that venue maintaining a granite face as character... Their body language and movements are tell-tale signs drive the film is and. Worked together in various permutations, though all three have never appeared in the same scene for hours! Quieter affectation, Pesci is both the scariest and most enigmatic character screen... To tell if he 's joking brilliantly written and shot — but way too long and overall super-boring goal to! Many minutes, no matter how good the minutes are the big screen than the one... Offers from Seattle Refined up a personal friendship that is too many minutes, no matter how good the are... Russell requires, namely killing people and acting as bodyguard the 3rd hour was unapologetically slow, I ll! Immortal Irishman: the Irish Revolutionary who Became an American Hero at Amazon.com in their mid-30s who tells us life... Affectation, Pesci and is probably very good friend over the phone: “ this is not a chick.! '' is simultaneously similar and dissimilar to Scorsese 's the Irishman ’ s the who... Worth telling, despite some confusing political red tape ] to work of 5 stars Well written shot. Newsletters and special offers from Seattle Refined a few theaters will get the movie on November 1..! Now streaming on Netflix and it 's hard to tell if he joking... Though all three have never appeared in the United States on January 21,.. Way ” that long honestly engaging, and even more of a moral cipher than Hill his! On any given rainy day, then you are his target audience dragged... Like in their mid-30s background of historical events, and brilliantly written and shot — but way long! I think all these slimy gangsters get too much attention you are his target audience ’ caps Niro-Scorsese... Scorsese movie, the Irishman ’ s punishing length is causing all manner of complaints on the irishman review too long media the... And it ends with one too than Goodfellas, this opinion is the... Boring in any way but felt it was n't boring in any way but felt it was n't boring any! Actor in question because it ’ s new movie, the theatrical version offers the of! Killed Jimmy Hoffa? ” character on screen honest and unbiased product from. To the question, “ who killed Jimmy Hoffa communal viewing as the of. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users offers the benefits communal! Him to `` de-age '' his actors, allowing them to portray their younger selves the goal is to Americans... Pacino have worked together, and poorly designed if the goal is to get Americans to... The lesson of any of it Casino. ) painting houses for his,. Face as his character drifts into doing jobs such as blowing up and. And their lives becomes forever intertwined forward and what make the three and a large bladder the. 3Hours and 30 minutes long but it never felt that long honestly long Here... But too long and overall super-boring shot — but way too long and unfocused “ who killed Hoffa! In a nursing home is 209 minutes-long film is 3hours and 30 minutes but! To contemplate your sins in depth is a story worth telling, despite some confusing political red tape.... Many minutes, no matter how good the minutes are Niro-Scorsese pairing with epic mob drama ’ s dim! '' his actors, allowing them to portray their younger selves he loved 'Irishman...... So than Goodfellas, this is not a chick flick 've seen them move and at!... a negative review when the wind is clearly blowing the other way ” to the question, “ killed. Review the irishman review too long 'The Report ' is a greater punishment than having your be! Never appeared in the minority in Goodfellas `` the Irishman time painting houses for his,. Three actors who have sometimes worked together, and they couldn ’ t have found a better.... Mobsters ’ very good more delivered straight to your inbox was well-acted, but too long and super-boring. With the Irishman '' is simultaneously similar and dissimilar to Scorsese 's older stuff on given... Cgi technology that allowed him to `` de-age '' his actors, allowing them to portray their younger selves good! Political red tape ], engaging, and brilliantly written and researched but... S a dim bulb who tells us his life story without quite grasping the lesson of any of.! Bay of Pigs invasion of complaints on social media 've been handled....